Embedding Employability in an Academy – A Case Study

Recently as a member of the Telford ASE I was involved in the designing and facilitating of a Personal Development Day for Abraham Darby Academy. Capgemini, the company I work for, partners with the academy as part of Business In The Community (BITC) and are invovled in a number of projects to help build a stronger community. The ASE were brought in to help tackle a particular challenge that is quite close to the hearts of many teachers and young people in education today.

How can the academy better prepare young people for life at work?

I wanted to share the thinking that went into the session, if you’re interested in seeing how it ran feel free to view the video summarising the day on the Capgemini YouTube Channel here

The first thing i want to make very clear is that this session was all about enabling the academy and its teaching staff to better itself, to grow on what it already did and do more. There were a number of questions that needed to be answered in the session in order to break this challenge down…

  1. Why does it matter that young people are prepared for work?
  2. What does ‘prepared for work’ really mean?
  3. What can we as a group impact and change?
  4. How do we go about making these changes happen?

Before we began though we wanted to break down faculty barriers and we wanted people to remember why they got into teaching in the first place. We wanted them to remember what their first job was like, how scary it was and start thinking about what would have helped them. To do this we created pretend camp fires for small groups to share stories, we created an environment that they felt free to talk and discuss and meet new people they hadnt worked with before.

Why does it matter that young people are prepared for work?

This might seem obvious but when you put this into the context of a community, a school, a teacher or even a pupil it becomes less obvious as school life is based around results and results are curriculum, academic and subject focussed. This makes it hard to incorporate other elements into an already busy school day and certainly distracts from other goals. Whilst academics and the curriculum have a significant impact on a young persons readiness for the work place there are a multitude of other things that also have critical roles.

To help the teachers see through this typical lens we asked the teachers and the pupils to complete a survey in the lead up to the session asking them questions about the state of employability skills in the academy. These questions enabled us to share with the teachers a current state view that was coming from themselves and their pupils as opposed to an outside influence or statistics that didnt necesarily apply to them. We followed this up with a clip from youtube called ‘A pep talk for teachers and pupils’ created by Kid President, we wanted to ensure the teachers understood the importance of the work they do and the importance for teachers to inspire and enable pupils to achieve. The video asks some great questions including…

What are you teaching the world?

Look for the awesome. Teachers see things, they see when you run behind the hall, they see when you’re passing notes, but they also see the person that we can all become someday; a writer or a speaker or Martin Luther King.

It’s time to be more awesome

We wanted the teachers to have intent to make a difference in their day to day working lives and help pupils be more prepared.

What does ‘prepared for work’ really mean?

Again this seems like a simple question but when you overlay different careers and university and everything else it comes muddied and complicated. We wanted to make it simple and enable the teachers to determine what it meant for themselves and enable them to create a shared view of this same point. To enable this we provided the teachers with a lot of different collateral including…

  • online research into employability skills
  • information on the compentencies that companies like Capgemini look for
  • asessment processes including putting them through a phone interview and group exercises
  • a number of their ex-pupils who now work for Capgemini

This part of the day wasn’t about educating the teachers explicitly, it was about providing them with an array of information they could engage with and allow them to start thinking more about what young people need from their education.

What can we as a group impact and change?

The challenge with this question is that most people naturally work with what they know and in the context they are used to as this is much easier, what we needed to do was put them in a new context. The context we operate in has a significant impact on the way we operate, it can change our perceptions, limit our thinking and drive a culture. We wanted the teachers to think big, we wanted them to break out of previous perceptions of what is and what is not possible.

To achieve this we set the scene of a better future, a future where the pupils of the academy are leaving as impressive people who are prepared for what lies beyond. We asked the teachers to tell us more about what this future might look like and specifically how it differs from the present. To ensure they took ownership of these changes we invited small groups to pitch their ideas to the rest of the teaching staff.

We used MG Taylor’s vantage points model (I have spoken about this model before on a previous blog) to help us to create a range of questions that helped the teachers to put detail into their vision of the future. This ensured that the participant group will think about the possibilities holistically. Given the nature of education and teaching we gave sustainability a focus for the conversation to ensure that whatever changes were suggested they were maintainable.

How do we go about making these changes happen?

Given pitched ideas this is the moment of truth, the moment the ideas start to become reality, the moment you can tell if an idea has landed. The big questions here are around how the idea will work and what needs to be done to ensure it happens. The challenge for most people is one of understanding how they will manage this new work on top of what feels like a full work load already. By this point in the event, the momentum had built and it can sometimes feel like anything is possible so practical considerations can be overlooked. It was important for us to ensure the teachers considered the implications of each idea cross faculties with people who are most keen to drive the idea forward and then work it through in faculty groups to understand who will do what and when.

We wanted to make a social difference and based on the feedback we received we achieved this. I hope that you have found this informative, if you have any questions, comments or thoughts feel free to share

Changing the Smell of the Place

For some time now I have been trying to understand how a point intervention (such as a collaborative workshop) can build momentum in a group of individuals that makes change easy.

At a recent session with my ASE colleagues I was introduced to a YouTube video by Professor Sumantra Ghoshal called “The smell of the place“.

Professor Ghosal talks about how people behave differently depending on the context of their environment. The more stifling the context the more constrained the behaviour, the more liberating the context the more innovative the behaviour. He mentions 4 key things that provide a liberating context…

  1. Stretch – not constraining but creating an exciting sense of purpose and ambition which generates pride in the work being done.
  2. Self discipline – management by commitment not by assuming compliance.
  3. Support – rather than control people support them, genuine change can be achieved if people believe their management hierarchy only exists to story their success.
  4. Trust – rather than a contract, we have a common goal so I won’t force you to do anything I will trust you to do it.

I would like to thank Franc @tobefranc for introducing me to this video and altering my view on the balance between facilitation and ownership. Let’s start by understanding these two words and then go on to look at how these are affected by understanding the impact of context.

Facilitation being the act of making easy or easier.
Ownership being the right of possession.

So how has my view on these things been affected by watching “the smell of the place”? Since I started in this industry of facilitation I have always been of the belief that it was about making the work and therefore the outcomes as easy as possible. This includes capturing all the work, structuring any sharing required between groups and even distribution of the output after the event. But what if this belief is flawed?

What if the act of making work easy creates a context of compliance, control and contract rather than one of self discipline, support and trust?  What if by facilitating to such extremes we have taken ownership away from those doing the work?

To enable participants to truly own the work they do during an intervention and allow it to live after facilitators need to do four things…

  1. Create the stretch by bringing the ambitons to life for every participant
  2. Enable participants to have self discipline by giving them the space to deliver the work in their own way
  3. Support them to deliver the work by providing guidance and the required resources rather than controlling them
  4. Trust them to record, capture and diseminate the work they do rather than doing it for them

These four things are not easy and require a mindset change for both facilitators, managers and the participants themselves but if it seems hard just remember this question…

What happens to the work after a point intervention if we don’t trust the participants during the intervention?

8 Tips to Using Social Media in Collaborative Work Events

A short while ago I ran my first 3 day ASE event with twitter embedded as a crucial component to the design. Given that the topic affected a much larger number of people than the participants who were able to physically participate in the event we decided to incorporate a twitter element to the session itself. At the start of the session we were looking for twitter to provide us a platform to…

  1. Spread the work and messages of the event
  2. Enable insight to be generated from outside the participant group

Once we realised that twitter would form an integral part of the event we created a plan to use it which was broadly split into three parts…

  1. Before the event – we would run a campaign to generate interest and start to encourage people to follow the work that was happening in the event.
  2. During the event – we would assign one of our team the responsibility of posing questions that were being discussed by the participant group and of bringing any key questions or input raised on twitter into the physical space.
  3. After the event – we would pull all of the twitter conversations and messages into a consolidated story that would be shared.

wpid-wp-1403102165299.png

Before the event

The most obvious thing for us was to determine a hash tag that would be easily recognisable and simple to follow (We used #GoodCareersGuide for this particular session) . With this created we needed to start spreading the word, we needed to start the event trending. To encourage interest in the event we decided that there were two important stakeholders to engage, each of which would need a slightly different approach.

Subject Matter Experts

During the design for the event a number of topics were identified as being crucial to the success of the work such as gamification and design thinking. Given the range of topics it was not practical to have all subject matter experts physically present for the whole event so it made sense to engage them in the work through the use of twitter. We identified those subject matter experts who we had personal connections with on twitter and invited them to contribute to the event. We shared the hash tag and informed them of when the event would be running. We followed this up by sharing the link to a website explaining what our client did and what they were looking to achieve.

Interested Parties

The second group of stakeholders we wanted to engage in the event were interested parties. This group included those individuals and organisational bodies who might end up using or being impacted by the solution. If you take a systems thinking approach to this group it is hard to identify specific individuals so we took a more open approach by asking prompting questions that would provoke people to think about the topic area and engage if they thought it made sense. Whilst doing this we actively asked people to retweet to their followers to widen the potential group. Lastly we looked to tweet behind the scenes photos and messages that would provide an insight for participants into the preparation going into the event and start to build excitement.

During the Event

During the event it is important to remember that there are a range of physical participants from the “I refuse to use twitter or any form of social media” to “I love social media and will use it at all times of the day”. Whilst extremes are not likely it is important to cater to the whole range and in doing so get as much insight and engagement as possible. For those who didnt want to or weren’t able to use social media we posted questions being raised in the event on our timeline, at the same time we took the most insightful comments and brought them into the physical space by scribing them up on a wall dedicated to thoughts and comments. To ensure that participants were able to see everything tweeted we had a number of LCD screens in the space with a twitter feed linked to the pre determined hashtag. Where appropriate we also looked to feed in comments to conversations that might benefit from the insight. For all participants we started the day by making it clear that we were using social media and informing people how we would be supporting it throughout the session itself. We used signs and graphics around the space to provide participants with twitter details and how they could get connected to our internet. There are well known difficulties of using something like social media in collaborative events as it can be a distraction to those who are engaged and an annoyance to those who are not. We tried to balance this by doing two things:

  1. Engage the unengaged using gamficiations and the subtle introduction of a twitter leaderboard. This was our first attempt at using leaderboards for such an endeavour and whilst we have definitely learned from the experience it it also increased engagement for the competitive participants.
  2. Highlight the distraction of social media. We looked to provide guidance to the participants as to when it was appropriate to use social media and when it was not. This is a difficult topic as it you first have to decide when it is and is not appropriate which isnt easy in itself. Do you allow it in small conversations where the work is less formal but as a smaller group the distraction is felt more greatly or do you allow it in plenary conversations with everyone present where the larger group can accommodate the distraction but it is more obvious to the whole group.

 

After the event

After the event, we wanted to share the whole event with both the physical and the virtual participants who were following our progress to provide one single point of view. To achieve this we created a story of the event that included the tweets from the participants, we did this using a tool called Storify which enabled us to embed tweets into a written story. In addition to this we have pulled together a marketting video that summarises the event. If you would like to see the Storify we created you can find it here.

8 Tips To Summarise

  1. Think about what you are trying to achieve with social media (spread the word, gain insight or both?)
  2. Plan your social media campaign in 3 parts (before, during and after)
  3. Identify a hash tag for the event and start using it as soon as possible
  4. Identify your audience and engage them on the media you want to use as early as possible
  5. Engage those unengaged in social media during the session (consider gamification tools such as leaderboarded)
  6. Determine when it is and is not appropriate to use social media during the event and tell participants
  7. Use multiple approaches to bring tweets into the event – LCD, ipad, hand written
  8. Summarise the event with a story to bring it to life for those not physically present

The 5 Is of creating engaging experiences

Engaging people in a concept or idea is hard, engaging them with work is even more so. The simple fact is that work in general is difficult, not necessarily because it is challenging but because it feels like something you don’t want to do. If it was something you wanted to do why do you need to get paid to do it? Whilst this is often the case, it isn’t always true, there are many people who love their jobs and the work they do and as a result they are engaged with that work and committed to achieving success.

I am sure everyone knows the famous story of President John F Kennedy visiting NASA, meeting a cleaner and asking him what his job was to which the cleaner supposedly replied “I help put men on the moon”. Regardless of whether this is factual or not, this is a great example of someone understanding the greater purpose of their job. It is entirely possible that another cleaner working in the same building having been asked the same question would have replied with “I keep the floors clean”. If I were the sort of person to gamble I would put money on the first cleaner doing a better job than the second.

The clear distinction between these two cleaners is a strong sense of purpose, the first cleaner understands why he is doing his job where as the second cleaner only understands what he needs to do and how he needs to do it. Simon Sinek talks about this in a recent TED talk on how create leaders inspire, which you can find here.

Now we understand the difference, how do you go about sharing the why so that people connect and engage with it? The model below was created with several of my colleagues to help us understand how to create such an experience…

IDENTIFY – a metaphor or story that helps you share your message as this will help people relate their personal and emotional experiences with the work you are trying to engage them with. It is important to consider the ramifications of using particularly emotional metaphors as the outcome can sometimes be extreme.

INFORM – explain work and the metaphor you are using and how it connects to the work that the participants are or will be doing. This needs to focus on why they are doing the work not what they are doing or how they need to do it. It is worth noting that not everyone will immediately and consciously understand why the metaphor is appropriate so it is essential that this connection be brought to attention at some point.

ILLUSTRATE – exemplify the metaphor by using one or more stories to show how the metaphor connects with the work. This enables the participants to start connecting with the topic, this can be done in a number of ways and doesn’t need to be someone verbally sharing stories. These stories are the emotional hook that will connect participants to the work so it is important to choose carefully.

INVOLVE – allow the participants to explore the metaphor and make it their own, provide content that enables them to start connecting on a deeper level with the story and the metaphor. Providing information on the metaphor will help on this front, whether that be through the use of reading materials or multimedia stories. There is a quote I would like to bring attention to here

Tell me and I will forget, show me and I may remember, involve me and I will understand

IMMERSE – turn the participants into actors within the metaphor, make them a part of the story by immersing them in the action. The small things matter here, attention to detail enables the participants to enter the metaphor without thinking about it. This can be achieved in a number of ways and works particularly well when the participants have experience of the metaphor before as they fill in the blanks that you weren’t able to create.

As an  example of this I was involved in an event some time ago where we were trying to engage our participants with the importance of quality. To do this we identified the airline industry as a good metaphor for the session given the impact of quality on safety. We didn’t want to just inform the participants that quality is important so we set about creating an experience.

We used an emergency landing story to base our experience on given the potential emotional connection people might have with plane crashes. Upon arrival our participants were given aeroplane tickets and boarding passes and asked to check their luggage, and were sent to a waiting room complete with screens displaying current flights. When it was time to start the participants were ushered to board the plane where their tickets were taken and they were sat down in aisles complete with safety cards and air. Sound was used to signify take off and a comical breaking noise was used to signify something had gone wrong followed by the words ‘BRACE’ ‘BRACE’ being spoken over a microphone system.

The whole experience was concluded with a news report sharing the cause of the emergency landing being an overlooked micro crack in the wing. This helped pull the whole thing together and bring it back to the original intent, quality is crucial not just to a company’s success but also to the service provided and avoiding the potential consequences that may result.

I have recently seen a video on alternate reality gaming which you can find here which has caused me to rethink the level of engagement you can create using multimedia and game mechanics. I would love to hear about any stories you may have of experiences you have helped create or participated in.

Model created in collaboration with several members of the Telford ASE

5 Principles for Great Visual Facilitation

Graphic facilitation is the use of visual media and imagery to guide a group of individuals to achieve a common goal. The imagery will be used differently by each individual in the group but overall the effect will be one of improved alignment in a similar way to meeting minutes. The greatest power of images over words is in the interpretation, after all…

A picture tells a thousand words

I have found that this form of facilitation is most powerful when used during conversations that have no predetermined end point apart from an alignment of the individuals present. This is because the images themselves become a structure for what had been discussed already and suggest potential topics for continuing the conversation.

I have been facilitating using graphics for several years note and over that time I have discovered five principles that have helped me.

The 5 Principles of Graphic Facilitation

The 5 Principles of Graphic Facilitation

1. Prepare for the conversation
It can often help to learn more about the topic before the conversation where possible as this can provide useful insight. This research can be done in a number of ways including reading relevant material or taking with the participants before hand. This isn’t always essential from a capture perspective but will help you to engage with the conversation and improve the end result.

2. Understand where the emotion is
Emotion is the critical component to creating a visual that facilitates a conversation. It is important to understand the topics that are creating the emotion in the conversation as these are the ones that need most guidance.

3. Create a foundation using keywords
Listen carefully to the conversation and keep your ear open for key points of debate. This is often easier when you know the topic being discussed but if you don’t the group can be used for guidance, consider their response as points are raised. you need to distil the essence of a message into a word or a short statement. These keywords help you to construct a map of the conversation that you can create imagery around.

Writing is an important part of any graphic facilitators tool kit and as such it is essential to practice your style. Remember it should be readable and quick as well as look good so think about it from another perspective.

4. Organise your work
Group common topics together, consider how they connect with each other. The important thing here is to ensure that relationships are clearly illustrated. This can be done through the use of boxes, clouds, arrows, lines and even scale. Depending on your medium it can be hard to rearrange so think about your layout before you start, considering where you want to leave room and what you want to be focused on is critical at all stages.

5. You don’t have to be Picasso…
To use graphic facilitation does not require you to be an amazing artist or illustrator. I’m not saying that the end product won’t look amazing if you are, I’m saying that to share its meaning a picture doesn’t have to be a work of art. Any imagery can be simplified down to icons using basic shapes such as circles, triangles and rectangles. Use these to construct icons that represent the pictures you are thinking of when you hear the keywords.

Do you have any advice you’d like to share?